Showing posts with label conservapedia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label conservapedia. Show all posts

Monday, January 24, 2011

Evolution Just the Facts Pt. 8

Hey all,

Alright we are almost done the review of conservapedia's evolution page! I have to admit the entire thing took me much longer than I thought that it would, but here we are, so let's continue:

Inflated Claims about Evolution Growing in Frequency and Intensity:

In recent times, despite their being little consensus on how evolution allegedly occurred according to the various theories of evolution, evolutionists have tried to convince the public of the supposed validity of the evolutionary position by increasing and frequently using the term "overwhelming evidence" or similar terms in relation to the alleged existence of evidence that supports their position. For example, prominent atheist and evolutionist Richard Dawkins claimed in an interview with journalist Bill Moyers that there is "massive evidence" for the theory of evolution.

- There is actually is consensus on how evolution occurred. The various theories explain different things that we see in the modern world today, in the lab and in the fossil record. Natural Selection and Sex Selection seem to be the biggest driving force in evolution, but there are other theories to describe the periods of status and rapid change (keep in mind rapid is still over 1000 years) as well as DNA, how it is formed and how it mutates.
- There is actually mountains of evidence for evolution, in the fossil record, morphology, DNA, embryonic studies, and many many more. Closing your eyes and plugging your ears does not make the evidence go away, no matter how much you don't want to believe it. Some of the most well documented evolutionary histories are the evolution of homo sapien (humans), whale evolution, bird evolution and horse evolution. If you do a google search on any one of those things you will find that there is a lot of evidence to support it.

The atheist and evolutionist Carl Sagan was an avid marijuana smoker who claimed marijuana gave him scientific insights. Given the lack of any real evidence for the evolutionary position and the aforementioned abundance of evidence against the evolutionary paradigm, Sagan's atheism and avid marijuana smoking no doubt helped inspire Sagan's atheistic pseudoscience fantasy that evolution was a "fact". The Barna Group found concerning atheism and morality that those who hold to the worldviews of atheism or agnosticism in America were more likely, than theists in America, to look upon the following behaviors as morally acceptable: illegal drug use; excessive drinking; sexual relationships outside of marriage; abortion; cohabitating with someone of opposite sex outside of marriage; obscene language; gambling; pornography and obscene sexual behavior; and engaging in homosexuality/bisexuality.

- This is probably one of the most outrageous statements that this article had to offer, and considering the content of this article that is impressive. So Sagan smoked marijuana, so what? He started smoking it in the 60s when it was not a crime. Even then, it doesn't really make much of a difference because studies have shown that marijuana has less mind altering affects than alcohol, but that is neither here nor there.
- This has nothing to do with the validity of the theory of evolution!
- I'm not in the mood to address the statement there about atheism and agnosticism, needless to say that I don't see a problem with things like premarital sex because as primates we are not inherently monogamous, I am pro-choice (and based on some studies a number of Christians are to with 43% being Protestant and 27% being Catholic source), cohabitation with someone of the opposite sex makes sense, in my opinion, if you are planning on marrying someone it makes sense to see if you can actually live together before making that commitment (which would likely result in a lower divorce rate), obscene language, well the definition of what is considered to be obscene changes over time, but there is a time and a place for every type of language even obscene language, gambling, hey if it's legal what's the problem so long as it is done in moderation? Pornography can actually help relationships by adding a little spice, obscene sexual behavior? I say to each their own (of course so long as everyone involved consents), and I'm not really sure what exactly they would consider to be obscene. Engaging in homosexuality/bisexuality, do you know how troubling it is for someone who is homosexual or bisexual to admit to themselves that they are gay or bi when they are indocritinated in a religion which tells them that they are an abomination even though God clearly made them that way? I'm willing to bet that it is the influence of Christianity and other anti-gay religions which leads gay/bi teens to attempt suicide...

Creation Vs. Evolution Videos:

Here is what they provide (l've left the links in case you want to see them for yourself):

Major Creation Science Organizations - Creation Vs. Evolution Videos:
Hickory Hammock Baptist Church Videos - Creation Vs. Evolution and Other Topics:
Other Creation Vs. Evolution Videos:


Now here are a few that I suggest:
Foundational Falsehoods of Creationism
Why Do People Laugh at Creationists?
Creationist Astronomy Propoganda (CRap) Debunked
Challenging the Discovery Institute to Discover
Why Young Earth Creationists Must Deny Gravity
Evidence for Evolution and Against Creationism
Origins: The Series
How Evolution Works
Transitional Fossils
Top 25 Creationist Fallacies
Evolution: How We Know it Happened & Why It Matters
Creationist Junk Debunked
From the Big Bang to Us - Made Easy
Creationism: Still Crazy After All These Years
Design Vs. Chance
Show Me the Intermediate Fossils!
Why Evolution is True (YouTube Channel)  - This channel is full of Evolution documentaries from the BBC, History Channel, Discovery, PBS, Channel 4, Nova, National Geographic and much more. I highly recommend this one!


So it's not hard to figure out which side of this "debate" I'm on, and although I have already explained why I think that "creation science" is dangerous I will explain a few other things about evolution which I think are important in society.

Evolution is fundamental to an understanding in biology, which leads to an understanding of medical science which in turn will help to save thousands if not millions of lives in the fields of epidemiology, cancer research, the research of AIDS and HIV as well as organ transplants, and many more which I couldn't even name.

Evolution is also fundamental in understanding what it means to be human as well as where we came from and where we are going as a species. Also by examining our non human primate cousins we can understand more about why we interact in ways that we do and even understand how some of our earliest ancestors might have interacted with one another.

DNA has helped us to understand more about evolution than we had before and it is through the premises of evolution that we understand things like children differ from their parents, and the application of DNA tells us how, and is also useful in determining paternity using evolutionary principles. These things will hold up in court, BTW.

The application of evolutionary principles are also helpful in the field of engineering, and chances are that you own something, or used something, or taken advantage of something which has been built using evolutionary principles.

Something that always occurs to me when this debate begins is the philosophical implications of the debate. I know that creationists want to believe that God created us as special and above the rest of the animal kingdom and are critical of evolutionary scientists because we know that we are a part of the animal kingdom, but they are missing the point. Creationism, and many other religions in my opinion, rob human beings of their potential. Creationism, in fact, robs all life of it's potential. Which story tells us more about ourselves? That we were specially created? Or that Life found a way to survive and thrive on a hostile planet, eventually leading to human beings who could reason, understand, and learn our history and place in the universe.


In the words of the late Carl Sagan, we are made of star stuff, we are a way for the universe to know itself. I think that is incredibly profound and meaningful. Take what you want from my opinions, but when evaluating the claims of both creation and evolution be critical, and take the time to investigate and look at the evidence. Also think about the applications and how both have helped humanity in general, I'll give you a hint, one has not helped humanity at all. 

Until next time,
DD

Sunday, January 23, 2011

Evolution Just the facts Pt. 7

Hey all,

Before I get started on my next installment of my critique of conservapedia's page of evolution I need to make a correction to my last one. The last point there I had said that gender is explained by evolutionary means when that is incorrect because gender is a social construct and the term I should have used was sex. Sorry for the slip, and now on to the critique:

Creation Scientists tend to win Creation-Evolution Debates:

- First I'm going to say that this is lousy proof that creation is true, and second I haven't witnessed a creationist win one of these debates, all I have seen is mis-definitions and shifting of the goal post... but let's look at what conservapedia has to say.

Creation scientists tend to win the Creation-Evolution debates and many have been held since the 1970's particularly in the United States. Robert Sloan, Director of Paleontology at the University of Minnesota, reluctantly admitted to a Wall Street Journal reporter that the "creationists tend to win" the public debates which focused on the creation vs. evolution controversy.

- only because they are not willing to accept the evidence as it is provided.

In August of 1979, Dr. Henry Morris reported in an Institute for Creation Research letter the following: “By now, practically every leading evolutionary scientist in this country has declined one or more invitations to a scientific debate on creation/evolution.”

- yep, only because having such debates gives the false impression that there is actually a debate to be had.

Morris also said regarding the creation scientist Duane Gish (who had over 300 formal debates): “At least in our judgment and that of most in the audiences, he always wins.” Generally speaking, leading evolutionists no longer debate creation scientists because creation scientists tend to win the creation vs. evolution debates.

- of course you think you win, and if a protestant were to debate a catholic both sides would think that they won. Aside from the fact that to have a debate gives the false impression that there is a actually a debate within the scientific community since the theory of evolution encompasses so many disciplines such as taxonomy, biology, paleontology, anthropology, geology, DNA, microbiology, biochemistry and so much more it is impossible for one person to be an expert in all of those fields and accurately represent all of the information, so when they are honest and say "I don't know" the creationists hail it as a victory. Just because that person doesn't know doesn't mean that no-one does and even if it isn't known doesn't mean that it is unknowable. Honestly if anyone ever claims to know everything be suspicious because they are lying to you.


Also, the atheist and evolutionist Richard Dawkins has shown inconsistent and deceptive behavior concerning his refusal creation scientists. Evolutionists and atheists inconsistency concerning debating creationists was commented on by the Christian apologetic website True Free Thinker which declared: "Interestingly enough, having noted that since some atheists refuse to debate “creationists” but then go on to debate some of those people but not others, it is clear that they are, in reality, being selective and making excuses for absconding from difficulties..."

- Dawkins has not been inconsistent, he used to debate with them when he was younger, and has done some documentaries where discussions come up, but recently he has decided no longer to give these people a platform because it gives the impression that they are on the same level as he is. Let's face it people who hold a Ph.D in theology cannot claim to understand biology or evolution.
- As for atheists in general, I cannot speak to their motavations, but I do know that some have an open request for debates with creationists, I watched a live blogtv event today where AronRa, Thunderf00t and DonExodus2 debated with QQOQQ and Nephlim Free, so the debates happen, and these people are not hand picked, they called into the show themselves, and the biggest problem during the debate is that both QQOQQ and Nephlim Free did not understand the science as it was explained to them, made up their own definitions for things like "species" and kept shifting the goal post, and when that is a trend that you see with EVERY creationist it gets old and frustrating so it is no wonder people don't want to debate because nothing is accomplished.

In an article entitled Are Kansas Evolutionists Afraid of a Fair Debate? the Discovery Institute states the following:
Defenders of Darwin's theory of evolution typically proclaim that evidence for their theory is simply overwhelming. If they really believe that, you would think they would jump at a chance to publicly explain some of that overwhelming evidence to the public. Apparently not.

- Well during the Dover Trial the prosecution did their work for them and kicked you out of the school science class because what you were proposing was religion, which is a breech of the first amendment. You would think that you would have learned after the Scopes Monkey Trial, but apparently not.

In 1994, the arch-evolutionist Dr. Eugenie Scott made this confession concerning creation vs. evolution debates:

- arch-evolutionist? What the hell does that mean?

During the last six or eight months, I have received more calls about debates between creationists and evolutionists than I have encountered for a couple of years, it seems. I do not know what has inspired this latest outbreak, but I am not sure it is doing much to improve science education. Why do I say this? Sure, there are examples of "good" debates where a well-prepared evolution supporter got the best of a creationist, but I can tell you after many years in this business that they are few and far between. Most of the time a well-meaning evolutionist accepts a debate challenge (usually "to defend good science" or for some other worthy goal), reads a bunch of creationist literature, makes up a lecture explaining Darwinian gradualism, and can't figure out why at the end of the debate so many individuals are clustered around his opponent, congratulating him on having done such a good job of routing evolution -- and why his friends are too busy to go out for a beer after the debate.

- Quote mined... here is where she was going with this:
What usually happens in these debates? Usually they take place at
the invitation of the other side, and usually they take place in a
religious setting or minimally under religious sponsorship.
That's the first problem. The audience that is most anxious to
come, and that will be recruited the most heavily, is the one that
supports the creationist. In the comparatively rare situation
where the debate is held on a college campus, the supporters of
good science and evolution are invariably in the minority in the
audience, whereas the creationist supporters seem to exercize every
effort to turn out their crowd. Don't be surprised to see church
busses from many local communities lined up outside the debate
hall. In some cases, the sponsors advertised only among the
faithful, posting up only a handful of flyers on campus. Guess who
came?
- read the full article here.

In 2010, the worldwide atheist community was challenged to a debate by Creation Ministries International as prominent atheists were speaking at a 2010 global atheist convention in Australia. Richard Dawkins, PZ Myers and other prominent atheists refused to debate Creation Ministries International.

Instead of speaking for these people, how about I let them speak for themselves. See this video.

Theory of Evolution, Liberalism, Atheism and Irrationality:

As alluded to earlier, in the United States, CBS News reported in October of 2005 that the Americans most likely to believe only in the theory of evolution are liberals.

- and that's bad because... Given your last Republican President I would say that liberals are more educated... and I've heard Sarah Palin speak... ok that was low, but if we were to do a poll about educated beyond high school, high school, high school drop outs and no high school I'll bet that the people with the least education accept creation and that trend can be seen changing as the people polled have more education, but that's only a theory.

The CBS News reported the following:
Americans most likely to believe in only evolution are liberals (36 percent), those who rarely or never attend religious services (25 percent), and those with a college degree or higher (24 percent).
White evangelicals (77 percent), weekly churchgoers (74 percent) and conservatives (64 percent), are mostly likely to say God created humans in their present form.

- See, people who are indoctrinated in religion and told by people they believe to be an authority that all of these scientists are atheists and just want to prove away god don't accept the theory of evolution... are we surprised? Does this do anything about the validity of the theory? No.


Given that liberalism is so prevalent in academia, it is not entirely surprising that college graduates are indoctrinated into the evolutionary paradigm via evolutionary propaganda.

-  By propaganda do you mean evidence? You know the things that students can see and test? Unlike the story of creation which has none of those thing? Then yes, there is evidence and if what you call propaganda is evidence then there is plenty of that.

Despite the aforementioned lack of evidence for the evolutionary position and the aforementioned counter evidential nature of the evolutionary paradigm, atheists and liberals persist in advocating the evolutionary paradigm. The continued support of the atheist and liberal community for the evolutionary paradigm is not surprising given the that the Wall Street Journal reported:
"...a comprehensive new study released by Baylor University yesterday, shows that traditional Christian religion greatly decreases belief in everything from the efficacy of palm readers to the usefulness of astrology. It also shows that the irreligious and the members of more liberal Protestant denominations, far from being resistant to superstition, tend to be much more likely to believe in the paranormal and in pseudoscience than evangelical Christians.... This is not a new finding. In his 1983 book "The Whys of a Philosophical Scrivener," skeptic and science writer Martin Gardner cited the decline of traditional religious belief among the better educated as one of the causes for an increase in pseudoscience, cults and superstition. He referenced a 1980 study published in the magazine Skeptical Inquirer that showed irreligious college students to be by far the most likely to embrace paranormal beliefs, while born-again Christian college students were the least likely.

- So you are trusting a study from a Christian University to report on Christians? Um alright... I used to be in the christian faith and you know the only reason I didn't buy in to those things when I was? Because I was told that it was evil! However a lack of belief in God does not automatically lead to skepticism and many of these pseudosciences are so general that they could apply to anyone. However, may I point out that belief in something which has no evidence is superstitious, and a belief in God is exactly that? Just saying...

Liberalism, Charles Darwin, and Denial of Creation:
Many liberals when faced with the compelling data for creation science and against the evolutionary paradigm irrationally attempt to suppress the evidence and engage in denial like the atheist Charles Darwin who late in life is reported to often have overwhelming thoughts that the world was designed.

- What evidence? You still haven't presented anything, all you are doing is trying to poke holes in evolution which aren't there. If you could provide evidence for creation and test it and prove it accurate then we would be given something to consider, but it still wouldn't by default prove that your specific god did it.
- 2 Darwin's doubts? That is a myth which has been circulating for a while, as was his deathbed conversion, and it still would have nothing to do with the theory itself!

Creation Ministries International describes such irrational thinking in the following manner:
Underpinning this abandonment of faith in God is the widespread acceptance of evolutionary thinking — that everything made itself by natural processes; that God is not necessary. There is ‘design’, such people will admit, but no Designer is necessary. The designed thing designed itself! This thinking, where the plain-as-day evidence for God’s existence (Rom. 1:19–20) is explained away, leads naturally to atheism (belief in no God) and secular humanism (man can chart his own course without God). Such thinking abounds in universities and governments today).

- Many evolutionists are Christians, and there are even some atheists who deny evolution, weird I know. But what about the Christian universities that teach geology and biology? Evolution is the theory that holds those disciplines together? How do the students deal with this? This documentary displays this struggle better than I could explain it.

The evolutionist and immunologist Dr. Scott Todd, an immunologist at Kansas State University, perfectly epitomized the irrational evolutionary denial of the evidence for creation in his correspondence to the science journal Nature. Dr. Scott wrote: "Even if all the data point to an intelligent designer, such an hypothesis is excluded from science because it is not naturalistic".

- exactly, it cannot be tested therefore it is not science. Science is defined as everything within the natural world and by definition God is outside of the natural world. Therefore it cannot be tested. It is really that simple, we still have a lot to learn about the processes here on Earth and through the universe before we can even consider looking for God.

Ben Stein Interview with Evolutionist Richard Dawkins

In the movie Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed, Ben Stein demonstrated the folly of evolutionism in his interview with the prominent evolutionist and atheist Richard Dawkins (A clip of the interview has been uploaded to YouTube ).

- link to video left so you can watch for yourself.

The Discovery Institute provides an transcript of part of the interview along with some commentary:
BEN STEIN: "What do you think is the possibility that Intelligent Design might turn out to be the answer to some issues in genetics or in evolution?"
DAWKINS: "Well, it could come about in the following way. It could be that at some earlier time, somewhere in the universe, a civilization evolved, probably by some kind of Darwinian means, probably to a very high level of technology, and designed a form of life that they seeded onto perhaps this planet. Now, um, now that is a possibility, and an intriguing possibility. And I suppose it's possible that you might find evidence for that if you look at the details of biochemistry, molecular biology, you might find a signature of some sort of designer."



- Dawkins is talking theoretically, and as a scientist he can't immediately exclude everything. However the details of biochemistry, molecular biology etc show the evidence of evolution, which is where Dawkins was going when the clip cut away from him.

Ho,ho! That is precisely what the Raelians say:
Years ago, everybody knew that the earth was flat. Everybody knew that the sun revolved around the earth. Today, everybody knows that life on earth is either the result of random evolution or the work of a supernatural God. Or is it? In "Message from the Designers", Rael presents us with a third option: that all life on earth was created by advanced scientists from another world.
Richard Dawkins and Rael; "clear thinking" kindred spirits!

- Wow... really? One of the theories of how life emerged on earth is known as pangeospera where a simple form of life from another world ended up on a primitive Earth. But again Dawkins was speaking theoretically. So I'm going to say to hell with you Discovery Institute. Not to mention that Stein and his producers were accused of real dishonesty about misrepresenting themselves and what they were doing... they were also sued by Yoko Ono for the use of the song Imagine which they used without permission.


In the Ben Stein/Richard Dawkins interview, Richard Dawkins was also asked what the probability is of God's existence is and a rationale for that estimation. Dawkins gave a very inept reply to Ben Stein concerning this issue.

- Dawkins states in the interview that he is uncomfortable putting a number on the likely hood of God's existence making him an honest man, he states that it is unlikely. See For Yourself.

Creationist Video of Richard Dawkins Being Stumped by a Creationist:
A video clip featuring Richard Dawkins became widely available to the public, showing Dawkins being stumped by a question from the creationist interviewer. A shortened version has been translated into 10 languages. The clip was part of an interview included in the video and DVD From a Frog to Prince, produced by Creation Ministries International about the genetic information required by evolution, and the interviewer is asking Dawkins for an example of genetic information arising from a mutation.
In later interviews, Dawkins claims that he was not stumped, but instead shocked when he realized that the interviewer was a creationist, and the video was edited in a way to make him look like he was unable to answer the question. However, the question came after he had that realization, and after the creationists negotiated with Dawkins and he agreed to continue. Richard Dawkins still hasn't provide any examples of genetic information being created by evolution.

- Read Dawkins own explanation of that video here.


Methodological Naturalism Ideology in Evolutionary Thought:
As mentioned earlier, evolutionary thought (which employs methodological naturalism) has had an influence on origin of life research as well (for example, a 2004 article in the International Journal of Astrobiology is titled On the applicability of Darwinian principles to chemical evolution that led to life).

- No! Evolution explains how life diversifies once it gets here, not how life originates. Stop trying to push this, this is not what they say, stop creating straw men!

The Nobel Prize winning biologist Francis Crick described himself as an agnostic with "a strong inclination towards atheism." In 1992, the science magazine Scientific American published an interview which explored Sir Francis Crick's belief in the hypothesis Directed Panspermia as a proposed hypthesis for the origin of life on earth.

- This is irrelevant, and not related to the theory of evolution.

Directed panspermia posits concerning the question of origin of life on earth that "organisms were deliberately transmitted to the earth by intelligent beings on another planet." Michael Behe wrote regarding the Scientific American interview the following:

- It doesn't mean intelligently seeded all the time, it could be by accidental means such as an asteroid. But this has nothing to do with the theory of evolution.

The primary reason Crick subscribes to this unorthodox view is that he judges the undirected origin of life to be a virtually insurmountable obstacle, but he wants a naturalistic explanation.

- I don't know why Crick believes this, if he does, and it doesn't matter because evolution has nothing to do with the origin of life.

When commenting on the hypothesis of Directed Panspermia Creation Ministries International wrote that Francis "Crick’s atheistic faith leads to absurd pseudoscience"

- Irrelevant and this is a straw man.

Suppression of Scientific Inquiry Concerning Alternate Theories of Origins:

There exists widespread suppression of creation science and intelligent design, ideas which offer alternative explanations of origins than do the various theories of evolution.

- Again evolution has nothing to do with the origin of life. However, "creation science" and intelligent design are not science. Science is not about saying "god did it" if that were the case we would have never made it out of the dark ages.

I think that is enough for tonight, there is only one section left in the article and I will get to it tomorrow,

Until next time,
DD

Evolution Just the facts Pt.6

Hey all,

So I have a wicked cold right now so I'm going to keep this one short like the last one. I am going to continue my critique of the conservapedia article on evolution, so let's get to it:

Social Effects of the Theory of Evolution:
There have been significant and negative social ramifications of the adoption of the theory of evolution. The theory has been foundational to Social Darwinism, Nazism, Communism, and racism.

- Alright, I'll give you Social Darwinism and racism, but not Nazism and Communism. In the case of Social Darwinism the theory was misapplied to the social structure of Victorian England and some societies since, where the belief was that the poor were poor because they were maladapted to the culture and they deserved to be poor, and later it was meant to imply that the strong were the ones who were wealthy, and they deserved to be wealthy because they were the strongest in society. Evolutionary scientists reject social darwinism as any reasonable person should.
- Racism, yeah I can't escape that one. As an anthropology student I am well aware of my discipline's involvement in perpetuating racism. There was a time when evolution was understood as "getting better" and in social anthropology produced a scale of primitive to civilized when examining contemporary cultures, but not as technologically advanced of the west. Anthropology, and the theory of evolution was also used to promote racist ideas, particularly that people of African decent were not as evolved as people of European decent. The discipline is transparent because we want to undo the harm we have done through promoting the colonial agenda, slavery and the destruction of many cultures. Just because a theory has unfavorable social consequences due to it's misunderstanding does not make it false. Christians are not willing to be this transparent, and even apply atrocities done by people with the same beliefs to atheists, don't believe me? Just wait.

The staunch evolutionist Stephen Gould admitted the following:
Haeckel was the chief apostle of evolution in Germany.... His evolutionary racism; his call to the German people for racial purity and unflinching devotion to a "just" state; his belief that harsh, inexorable laws of evolution ruled human civilization and nature alike, conferring upon favored races the right to dominate others; the irrational mysticism that had always stood in strange communion with his brave words about objective science - all contributed to the rise of Nazism. - Stephen J. Gould, "Ontogeny and Phylogeny," Belknap Press: Cambridge MA, 1977, pp.77-78)

- I find it interesting that in one part of this article you are condemning Haeckel for falsifying his drawings, and Gould for this theory of Punctuated Equilibrium, and are not using both as an expert here, but let's examine this statement for a second, and ignore the deliberately negative image you paint of the late Stephen J. Gould. It seems to me that Haeckel was towing the party line, no more than Rush Limbaugh was when he suggested killing all but two liberals for universities so people would know what they stood for (I know it's a low blow, but I couldn't help it). But as I have already mentioned, anthropologists did have a hand in this and it was the Holocaust which changed our minds.

Adolf Hitler wrote the following evolutionary racist material in his work Mein Kampf:
If nature does not wish that weaker individuals should mate with the stronger, she wishes even less that a superior race should intermingle with an inferior one; because in such cases all her efforts, throughout hundreds of thousands of years, to establish an evolutionary higher stage of being, may thus be rendered futile.

- So the only article you offer for this quote is a newspaper article criticizing the church apologizing to Darwin and forcing me to wade through Mein Kampf myself to see if this was quote mined or not... thanks... back in a few... back, and to my surprise it is not in Mein Kampf... so this quote appears to be fabricated and misapplied to Hitler... nice work guys... way to check your sources.

Hitler also wrote in Mein Kampf:
The stronger must dominate and not blend with the weaker, thus sacrificing his own greatness. Only the born weakling can view this as cruel, but he, after all, is only a weak and limited man; for if this law did not prevail, any conceivable higher development (Hoherentwicklung) of organic living beings would be unthinkable.

- Alright Mein Kampf here we go again... wow.... you quote mined Hitler... nice... here is the whole thing:
Any crossing of two beings not at exactly the same level produces a medium between the level of the two parents. This means: the offspring will probably stand higher than the racially lower parent, but not as high as the higher one. Consequently, it will later succumb in the struggle against the higher level. Such mating is contrary to the will of Nature for a higher breeding of all life. The precondition for this does not lie in associating superior and inferior, but in the total victory of the former. The stronger must dominate and not blend with the weaker, thus sacrificing his own greatness. Only the born weakling can view this as cruel, but he after all is only a weak and limited man; for if this law did not prevail, any conceivable higher development of organic living beings would be unthinkable.
The consequence of this racial purity, universally valid in Nature, is not only the sharp outward delimitation of the various races, but their uniform character in themselves. The fox is always a fox, the goose a goose, the tiger a tiger, etc., and the difference can lie at most in the varying measure of force, strength, intelligence, dexterity, endurance, etc., of the individual specimens. But you will never find a fox who in his inner attitude might, for example, show humanitarian tendencies toward geese, as similarly there is no cat with a friendly inclination toward mice...

To bring about such a development is, then, nothing else but to sin against the will of the eternal creator.
- Seems to me that Hitler didn't accept the evolutionary theory, and promoted the idea of a creator, so let it be known that Hitler was Catholic, and thought by killing the Jews that he was preforming Gods will of punishing the Jews for killing Jesus, and this was not the first time the Jews had been persecuted for the same thing. So can we move on from Hitler now?

Robert E.D. Clark in his work Darwin: Before and After wrote regarding Hitler's evolutionary racism:
The Germans were the higher race, destined for a glorious evolutionary future. For this reason it was essential that the Jews should be segregated, otherwise mixed marriages would take place. Were this to happen, all nature’s efforts 'to establish an evolutionary higher stage of being may thus be rendered futile' (Mein Kampf).

- What it seems Hitler was worried about was diluting the German bloodline, which was no different than royal families intermarrying to keep the bloodline "pure". As for the quotation Clark used... I couldn't find it in Mein Kampf.

Dr. Robert E.D. Clark also wrote:
“Adolf Hitler’s mind was captivated by evolutionary teaching — probably since the time he was a boy. Evolutionary ideas — quite undisguised — lie at the basis of all that is worst in Mein Kampf — and in his public speeches.”

- So the only citation you give for this is another christian website which is trying to explain the Holocaust, and from what I have found in Mein Kampf Hitler talks about The Creator, more than he talks about evolution and seems to have believed that what he was doing was God's will. 

Richard Hickman, in his work Biocreation, concurs and wrote the following:
It is perhaps no coincidence that Adolf Hitler was a firm believer in and preacher of evolutionism. Whatever the deeper, profound, complexities of his psychosis, it is certain that [the concept of struggle was important for]. . . his book, Mein Kampf clearly set forth a number of evolutionary ideas, particularly those emphasizing struggle, survival of the fittest and extermination of the weak to produce a better society. 

- Oh, so now accepting the evolutionary theory leads to a psychosis? Hitler used eugenics to promote his racial purity, which was based upon Lamarkian Evolution, which I have pointed out before. Note how all the quotes leave out the part about Hitler being Catholic, and that he didn't accept the theory of Evolution as proposed by Darwin.

Noted evolutionary anthropologists Sir Arthur Keith conceded the following in regards to Hitler and the theory of evolution: “The German Fuhrer, as I have consistently maintained, is an evolutionist; he has consciously sought to make the practices of Germany conform to the theory of evolution”

- Whoever quote mined this one did a decent job, but here is the whole thing: The German Fuehrer, as I have consistently maintained, is an evolutionist; he has consciously sought to make the practice of Germany conform to the theory of evolution. He has failed, not because the theory of evolution is false, but because he has made three fatal blunders in its application.
- Though I disagree that Hitler was an Evolutionist, but a fan of Lamark's Theory.

Dr. Josef Mengele's evolutionary thinking was in accordance with social Darwinist theories that Adolph Hitler and a number of German academics found appealing. Dr. Joseph Mengele studied under the leading proponents the "unworthy life" branch of evolutionary thought. Dr. Mengele was one of the most notorious individuals associated with Nazi death camps and the Holocaust.Mengele obtained a infamous reputation due to his experiments on twins while at Auschwitz-Birkenau.

- Wow... that's quite the accusation, how about this one, "a belief in God makes one susceptible to stoning people to death, burning people at the stake and torturing them until they admit to crimes they didn't commit" How does that feel? I don't know what Mengele personally believed in relation to evolution, but his practices were atrocious and no one with a conscience would argue that, but to blame his actions on evolution... well let's put it this way. Mengele also likely accepted the theory of gravity and germ theory, does that mean they were wrong?

Prominent evolutionist and atheist Richard Dawkins stated the following regarding Adolf Hitler in an interview: “What’s to prevent us from saying Hitler wasn’t right? I mean, that is a genuinely difficult question." The interviewer of Richard Dawkins wrote the following regarding the Richard Dawkins comment about Hitler: "I was stupefied. He had readily conceded that his own philosophical position did not offer a rational basis for moral judgments. His intellectual honesty was refreshing, if somewhat disturbing on this point."

- I think the point Dawkins was trying to make was about the difference between objective and subjective morality. If there was such a thing of objective, or God given morality, we may not all understand it and be wrong about some of our ideas, and that if something were commanded by God it would be moral, and since Hitler thought that he was doing Gods will he might have been commanded to do it. See the problem here?

B. Wilder-Smith wrote the following regarding Nazism and the theory of evolution:
One of the central planks in Nazi theory and doctrine was …evolutionary theory [and] … that all biology had evolved … upward, and that … less evolved types … should be actively eradicated [and] … that natural selection could and should be actively aided, and therefore [the Nazis] instituted political measures to eradicate … Jews, and … blacks, whom they considered as “underdeveloped”.

- Alright, instead of blaming it on Lamarkian Evolution, let's look at another theory which was prevalent at the time, and this was the Great Chain of being, by which all life on Earth was ranked, with humans, angels and god at the top.  This is what happens when the great chain of being is applied with evolution. Ever seen the picture of the evolution of man? This is called the march of progress, and it shows an ideology that doesn't exist. Evolution doesn't make one species better than another one, or one "race" better than another, but it does when you use the Great Chain of Being with it.

Pulitzer Prize winning author Marilynne Robinson wrote the following regarding Hitler's racism in the November 2006 issue of Harper’s Magazine:
While it is true that persecution of the Jews has a very long history in Europe, it is also true that science in the twentieth century revived and absolutized persecution by giving it a fresh rationale — Jewishness was not religious or cultural, but genetic. Therefore no appeal could be made against the brute fact of a Jewish grandparent... There is indeed historical precedent in the Spanish Inquisition for the notion of hereditary Judaism. But the fact that the worst religious thought of the sixteenth century can be likened to the worst scientific thought of the twentieth century hardly redounds to the credit of science."

- What she seems to be saying is that being Jewish is a heritage, just like being Irish is a heritage, but being born Jewish also has a culture and belief system that comes with it, but I also know a lot of Irish Catholics... So it was the combination of the two, culture and heritage, which was the problem. Nowhere does she mention evolution and it was no secret that Hitler was a racist.

As noted earlier, evolutionary ideas significantly influenced the thinking of the nineteenth and twentieth-century Communists. Karl Marx wrote in a letter the following, ""Darwin's book is very important and serves me as a basis in natural science for the class struggle in history." Darwin's ideas also influenced the thinking of Engels, Vladimir Lenin, and Joseph Stalin.

- I'm going to let the guys over at rational wiki handle this one:
- Guilk writes of Social Darwinism, and its link, if any, to real Darwinism:
- To a scientist, it's sheer foolishness to try to draw moral lessons from natural phenomena. Most of the so-called "Social Darwinists" were simply looking for justification for their already on-going exploitation of the poor. If they hadn't found it by misreading Darwin, they would have had to go back to misreading the Bible.
- He hits the nail on the head. The writer of a text can't be held liable for the creative, even genocidal, misinterpretations of the original text... just as Gulik says. Most of the objections to evolutionary science from creationists seem to relate to the argument that evolution somehow co-opts the moral role of philosophy & religion. Nothing could be farther from the truth. Evolution offers a how; some people may try to infer a why from the bare facts, but those people are either looking too hard, or too easily offended, or (most likely) both.

Governments under the banner of atheistic communism have caused the death of somewhere between 40 million to 260 million human lives. Dr. R. J. Rummel, professor emeritus of political science at the University of Hawaii, is the scholar who first coined the term democide (death by government). Dr. R. J. Rummel's mid estimate regarding the loss of life due to communism is that communism caused the death of approximately 110,286,000 people between 1917 and 1987.

- You know what I'm not going to bother trying to argue numbers here because everyone comes up with their own and will omit things, but what I will say is that evolution is not the cause of these deaths, it was the Great Chain of being, and political ideas, not a theory about biology... sorry. I could point out all the fighting done throughout history done by people who believed that they were God's chosen people and that everyone else was less than themselves, but I wouldn't sink that low.

Previously it was mentioned that evolutionary ideas contributed to the scourge of racism. Charles Darwin and Thomas Huxley contributed greatly to the theory of evolution broadly being accepted in the 1900s. Darwin, Huxley, and the 19th century evolutionists were racist in sentiment and believed the white race was superior.  For example, Charles Darwin wrote in his work The Descent of Man and Selection in Relation to Sex the following:
At some future period not very distant as measured by centuries, the civilised races of man will almost certainly exterminate and replace the savage races throughout the world. At the same time the anthropomorphous apes...will no doubt be exterminated. The break between man and his nearest Allies will then be wider, for it will intervene between man in a more civilised state, as we may hope, even than the Caucasian, and some ape as low as the baboon, instead of as now between the Negro or Australian and the gorilla.

- Alright so this one wasn't quote mined, but you have to understand that Darwin lived in a time when these ideas were the norm and it was widely believed that the people of different cultural heritages were different races entirely. It is not until fairly recently that we know that there is only one race of humans, the human race, and we know that through DNA. In Darwin's time it was thought that they were from difference races and that accounted for the difference in technologies, but that does not mean that Darwin was a racist. If you read the Voyage of the Beagle you will see that Darwin was deeply upset with how the racial minorities were treated.

John C. Burnham wrote, in the journal Science, the following in regards to the theory of evolution and racism:
After 1859, the evolutionary schema raised additional questions, particularly whether or not Afro-Americans could survive competition with their white near-relations. The momentous answer was a resounding no.... The African was inferior — he represented the missing link between ape and Teuton."

- In 1859 this was the case... and I repeat again we have learned much more since then. It also is important to note again this is not evolution's fault, it is the misinterpretation of it for racist means which is the problem. Please don't point the finger at us and say racism when This passage from Genesis 9:23-25 has been used to perpetuate the slavery of the African's:
23 But Shem and Japheth took a garment and laid it across their shoulders; then they walked in backward and covered their father’s naked body. Their faces were turned the other way so that they would not see their father naked.
 24 When Noah awoke from his wine and found out what his youngest son had done to him, 25 he said,
   “Cursed be Canaan!
   The lowest of slaves
   will he be to his brothers.”
- Hello pot this is kettle....

Harvard University's Stephen Jay Gould stated, "Biological arguments for racism may have been common before 1859, but they increased by orders of magnitude following the acceptance of evolutionary theory." Recent racism directed at Michelle Obama was the result of evolutionary racism.

- I'm Canadian, I don't know the particulars about this Michelle Obama story... sorry. But what Gould said was correct and as I have said above we learn about this in anthropology because the discipline is transparent and wants to undo the harm done.

Also, according to atheist philosopher David Stove the theory of evolution was influential in regards to the sexual revolution.

- So? The sexual revolution was a good thing... wasn't it? Or are you saying that women controlling their fertility is a bad thing? Well if that is the case it will be the topic of another blog post later on.

Genetics, Homosexuality, Evolutionary Paradigm, and Creation Science:

In 1993, Professor Miron Baron, M.D., the renowned medical researcher and Professor at Columbia University, wrote in BMJ (British Medical Journal) that there is a conflict relative to the theory of evolution and the notion of genetic determinism concerning homosexuality. Dr. Baron wrote "...from an evolutionary perspective, genetically determined homosexuality would have become extinct long ago because of reduced reproduction." In the United States, liberals are more likely to believe in the theory of evolution. Also, in the United States, twice as many liberals as conservatives (46% versus 22%) believe people are born homosexual and liberals generally have more favorable opinions about homosexuality. Given Dr. Miron Baron's commentary about homosexuality, many American liberals are inconsistent on the issues of evolution and homosexuality.

- Alright let's examine this statement logically shall we? Yes it is impossible for two men or two women to reproduce, but they have kids. That's right gay men have a child with a woman as the surrogate mother, and gay women have children using donated sperm. So there is a possibility that if there is a "gay gene" it could easily be passed to the next generation.
- Secondly we still don't know exactly why homosexuals are homosexual, it could be genetics, it could be an imbalance of chemicals in the womb, or it could be a number of factors which happen during development, so these statements are meaningless.
- I apologize if it seemed that I was taking a hetero normative point of view there, I have already stated that I'm bisexual and I honestly don't believe that heterosexuality is the "norm" I believe in the spectrum of sexuality and that anyone could fit anywhere on that spectrum.

An individual's beliefs regarding creation science/creationism and the theory of evolution appear to influence their views on homosexuality. Creationist scientists and creationist assert that the theory of evolution cannot account for the origin of gender and sexual reproduction. Creation Ministries International states: "Homosexual acts go against God’s original design of a man and a woman becoming one flesh — see Genesis 1 and 2, endorsed by Jesus Himself in Matthew 19:3–6." In addition, the vast majority of creation scientists reject the notion of genetic determinism concerning the origin of homosexuality.

- Well it can account for the origin of gender and sexual reproduction see here, and here. But that aside the theory of evolution does account for homosexuality... did you know that the world is overpopulated? Think that if we have people who do not reproduce this might help that problem?
- I'm not going to try to argue the bible here, I believe that it was a book written by men, and was not the divine word of god, if that is what you believe then there is nothing I can do to argue against you, but you do realize that by following this dogma and trying to keep the right to marry away from homosexuals you are violating the golden rule right? Just thought that I would point that out.
- yeah creation scientists cannot fathom a god who would "make" people homosexual, but that might indeed be the case... get over it. I didn't choose to be bisexual, I am bisexual, I am attracted to both men and women, and I don't see anything wrong with that, I believe that love is love and it comes in many forms, and homosexuality is one of those forms.

Common Behavior of Online Evolutionists:
In February of 2010, the news organization The Telegraph reported that atheist and evolutionist Richard Dawkins was "embroiled in a bitter online battle over plans to rid his popular internet forum for atheists of foul language, insults and 'frivolous gossip'." Given that Wired Magazine and Vox Day declared for various reasons that atheists tend to be quarrelsome, socially challenged men, it is not surprising the online dispute was bitter. In addition, Richard Dawkins has a reputation for being abrasive.

- Well this has nothing to do with Evolution, but does have to do with atheists, and I thought that I would point out why online atheists come across the way that they do. They are like this because everything that any theist has put forward is something that we have heard before, and we get tired of hearing the same thing over and over, it's really that simple. This video sums it up nicely.

In 2010, the Christian apologetics website True Free Thinker wrote:
Scienceblogger Chad Orzel described the commentators on PZ Myers ' Scienceblogs.com site Pharyngula, and other Scienceblogs.com commentators, as "screechy monkeys."

- Well what were the creationists doing? Were they repeating things over and over "there are no transitional forms" and things of that like without bothering to do the research that we suggest they do? Information is so easily accessed now, and it's not hard to imagine that although they could, they don't.

In addition, there is a widespread problem with atheist cyberbullying on YouTube toward Christian and creationist YouTube channels. CreationWiki has developed a web page entitled Creationist YouTube video designed to show creationists how to thwart atheist/evolutionist cyberbullies.

- I left the link there because it suggests things like URL redirects, disabling comments, blocking, and using the one star votes... which is something that every creationist uses. Now about this supposed cyberbullying... it happens on both sides...  a lot of atheists often get told that they will go to hell and how much people hope they will die etc etc... this has nothing to do with the validity of the theory of evolution mind you.

That's all for tonight, I'm going to get some sleep,

Until next time,
DD

Friday, January 21, 2011

Evolution Just the facts Pt. 5

Hey all,

Well I do have some homework to do over the weekend so I'll make this one short... so without further ado here is my continuation of the critique of conservapedia's evolution page:

Richard Dawkins and Pseudoscience:

Within the evolutionary science community and the creation science community, evolutionist and atheist Richard Dawkins has faced charges of engaging in pseudoscience and also has faced charges of committing elementary errors.

- Oh I can't wait to hear how you are going to justify this...

The website True Free Thinker notes:
Moreover, note that with regards to “assertions without adequate evidence” evolutionary biologist and geneticist, Prof. Richard Lewontin, referenced Carl Sagan’s list of the “best contemporary science-popularizers” which includes Richard Dawkins. These authors have, as Lewontin puts it, “put unsubstantiated assertions or counterfactual claims at the very center of the stories they have retailed in the market.” Lewontin specifically mentions “Dawkins’s vulgarizations of Darwinism” (find details here and here). Even renowned evolutionary biologists H. Allen Orr, David Sloan Wilson, and Massimo Pigliucci have called into question the power that Dawkins once had as an intellectual, since he has made elementary errors in The God Delusion.

- So the only source that you site is a creationist website, but provide no sources for H. Allen Orr, David Sloan Wilson, and Massimo Pigliucci questioning Dawkins power as an intellectual. And their only reference for the book you are critical of making errors is on your webpage where you give a single sentence as an explanation for the complex points that Dawkins makes in his book. Sorry Conservapedia, this contrived attempt to discredit Dawkins doesn't work on me, and I doubt it would work on any other skeptical person.

Age of the Earth and Universe and the Theory of Evolution:

As far as the evolutionary timeline posited by the evolutionary community, the various theories of evolution claim that the earth and universe are billions of years old and that macroevolutionary processes occurred over this time period.

- Yes, you are right, but why do I get the feeling that you're not going to stop there, instead you are going to try to make the claim that the Earth is only 6000 years old... but you know how wrong that is right?

William R. Corliss is a respected cataloger of scientific anomalies and the science magazine New Scientist had an article which focused on Mr. Corliss's career as a cataloger of scientific anomalies. Mr. Corliss has cataloged scores of anomalies which challenge the old earth geology paradigm. Young earth creationist hold the earth and universe is approximately 6,000 years old.

- Sigh... alright which anomalies? Since I don't have access to a New Scientist Journal back in 1977... which is out of date.. in science the oldest literature considered valid is about 10 years ago since things change so quickly.

Young earth creationist scientists state the following is true: there are multiple lines of evidence pointing to a young earth and universe; the old earth and universe paradigm has numerous anomalies and uses invalid dating methods, and there are multiple citations in the secular science literature that corroborate the implausibility of the old earth and universe paradigm.

- Well if our dating system is invalid why do you guys use it to test validity of things like the Shroud of Turin, a piece of wood you believe to come from the ark, and various other religious icons? Is it that you agree that the only way to be taken seriously is to use the methods we do, and it doesn't help your case to poke holes in them? Well the dating methods we use have been verified accurate over and over to see how some of them work watch this video, this one and this one. Now how about we examine a dating technique that even a child can understand, dendochronology which is using tree rings to date things, and even those can prove that the Earth is at least 11,000 years old see here.

Scientific Community Consensus and the Macroevolution Position:
A 1997 Gallup poll indicated that 55% of United States scientists believed that humans developed over a period of millions of years from less developed forms of life and that God had no part in the process, 40% believed in theistic evolution, and 5% of scientists believed that God created man fairly much in his current form at one time within the last 10,000 years. As noted earlier, in 2007, "Discovery Institute's Center for Science and Culture...announced that over 700 scientists from around the world have now signed a statement expressing their skepticism about the contemporary theory of Darwinian evolution."

- Well that's a relief, at least they didn't just make up some ridiculous number... but as I also stated earlier that list is fraudulent and you can see why again here.

Poll results regarding the amount of scientists who are skeptical or opposed to the evolutionary view could be underreporting the actual amount of scientists who are skeptical of the evolutionary view or hold the creation science view. Poll results may not be as precise as they could be as creation science organizations report widespread discrimination against scientists who hold the creation science view. On April 18, 2008 a film documentary by Ben Stein entitled Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed! was released to the public which documents the suppression of scientific freedom of scientists who are critical of the evolutionary position. Such suppression is not surprising given that a poll among United States scientists showed that approximately 45% of scientists believed there was no God. In addition, a survey found that 93% of the scientists who were members of the United States National Academy of Sciences do not believe there is a God. Given this state of affairs, a future paradigm shift from the theory of evolution to a creation science position could be slow given the worldviews of many scientists. 

- Given the fraudulent nature of the list created I think that the numbers work.. and that those 5% need to take an introductory evolutionary biology lesson and if they wish to continue themselves scientists they will take the evidence seriously.
- I lost a lot of respect for Mr. Stein when he made this movie. The problem for Mr. Stein is that science is not a democracy, and nor should it be. The process of peer review gives validation to the hypothesis that make the most sense, and can provide the most testable outcomes. I can guarantee so long as there are people out there who value the truth that paradigm shift will NEVER happen. Not only that, but creation science would also set society back to a point which would be very frightening.

Also, the current scientific community consensus is no guarantee of truth. The history of science shows many examples where the scientific community consensus was in error, was scientifically unsound, or had little or no empirical basis. For example, bloodletting was practiced from antiquity and still had many practitioners up until the late 1800s. In his essay, A Paradigm Shift: Are We Ready? , Niranjan Kissoon, M.D. wrote the following: "...history is rife with examples in which our best medical judgment was flawed. The prestigious British Medical Journal begun in 1828 chose the name Lancet to signal its scholarly intent and cutting edge therapy."

- That is why nothing in science is claimed as 100% true, because every theory must be falsifiable, and until that point it will be used. Because mistakes were made in the past does not mean that the entire scientific inquiry should be abandoned because new and exciting things are being discovered every day, and these discoveries do change how the world was viewed. BTW, are the religious willing to change their minds if they happen to be wrong? Not likely, but scientists will test and retest hypothesis' and if they turn out to be wrong they move on. Creationism cannot be tested, therefore it cannot be verified or falsified, and should not be considered science.

Also, in regards to modern medical science, in a 1991 BMJ (formerly called the British Medical Journal) article, Richard Smith (editor of BMJ at the time) wrote the following: "There are 30,000 biomedical journals in the world...Yet only about 15% of medical interventions are supported by solid scientific evidence, David Eddy professor of health policy and management at Duke University, told a conference in Manchester last week. This is partly because only 1% of the articles in medical journals are scientifically sound and partly because many treatments have never been assessed at all." Next, alchemy was at one time considered to be a legitimate scientific pursuit and was studied by such notable individuals as Isaac Newton, Robert Boyle, Roger Bacon, and Gottfried Leibniz. Given the aforementioned weaknesses in the evolutionary position and given that the history of science shows there have been some notable paradigm shifts, the scientific consensus argument for the macroevolutionary theory certainly cannot be called an invincible argument.

- This quote is not in the article that they cited... I know... I looked. Which makes me believe that this is may not only be quote mined, but fabricated. What difference does it make that Newton was an Alchemist, are you going to attack the theory of gravity next? We would never claim it an an invincible argument, remember you agreed that all theories should be falsifiable? Not to mention that macroevolution (better known as speciation) has occurred... don't believe me? see here.

In addition, biblical creationists can point out examples where the scientific community was in error and the Bible was clearly correct. For example, until the 1970s the scientific consensus on how lions killed their prey was in error and the Bible turned out to be right in this matter. Also, for centuries the scientific community believed that snakes could not hear and the 1988 edition of The New Encyclopedia Britannica stated the snakes could not hear but that was mistaken and the Bible was correct in this matter. In addition, 19th century European naturalists were wrong concerning a matter regarding ant behavior and the Bible was correct. Many creationists such as the creationist at Creation Ministries International and CreationWiki assert that the Bible scientific foreknowledge the Bible contains knowledge that shows an understanding of scientific knowledge beyond that believed to exist at the time the Bible was composed. In addition, Christianity had a profound influence in regards to the development of modern science.

- 1. The lion thing... alright, I'll give you that, only because the reference you gave does say that lions strangled rather than bit the neck or broke the neck with a paw swat as was believed...  however, I do not know how widely this was believed, or if the quotes used on the website you referenced were mined or not because lions can kill smaller prey with the swat of a paw, and may bite through the necks of the smaller prey... so I'm not ready to completely believe you.
- 2. snakes, same deal as lions, I don't know how widely this is believed but.... this is the only biblical reference you give for a snake being able to hear is:
The wicked go astray from the womb, they err from their birth speaking lies.They have venom like the venom of a serpent, like the deaf adder that stops its ear, so that it does not hear the voice of charmersor of the cunning enchanter. (58:3-4)
Now to me this doesn't sound like snakes can hear, but you be the judge... you would have thought they would be clearer if they wanted to say snakes can hear.
- 3. As for some other scientific claims in the bible... well I suggest watching this video and this one and see how scientifically accurate the bible really is....
- 4. Yeah Christianity has had a profound influence on modern science... a negative one. I have two words for you "stem cells"!

Alright, I think that's enough for now, next time we will begin with the Social Effects of the Theory of Evolution...

Until Next Time,
DD

Thursday, January 20, 2011

Evolution Just the facts Pt. 4

Hi all,

So it has come to my attention that I missed a character in my last post, Malcom Reynolds from Firefly/Serenity who has lost his faith. To my friend who pointed that out, I will be using him as an example in an upcoming post looking at the popular theme in pop culture of the "crisis of faith". So stay tuned.

Now to continue my discussion of Conservapedia's Evolution page:

Statements of Design:

Phillip E. Johnson cites Francis Crick in order to illustrate the fact that the biological world has the strong appearance of being designed:
"One of the world's most famous scientists, probably the most famous living biologist, is Sir Francis Crick, the British co-discoverer of the structure of DNA, a Nobel Prize winner... Crick is also a fervent atheistic materialist, who propounds the particle story. In his autobiography, Crick says very candidly biologists must remind themselves daily that what they study was not created, it evolved; it was not designed, it evolved. Why do they have to remind themselves of that? Because otherwise, the facts which are staring them in the face and trying to get their attention might break through. What we discovered when I developed a working group of scientists, philosophers, et al., in the United States was that living organisms look as if they were designed and they look that way because that is exactly what they are." - Evolution And Christian Faith by Phillip E. Johnson

- I don't know exactly where Johnson got this quote because in the source conservapeida sites there is no references to find what Crick meant by those words, if he said them. What it sounds like to me is that he is addressing is the appearance of design and explaining that the appearance of the design and how things seem suited to their environment, but may have been talking about the natural processes of design, the evolutionary process, the environment and the natural processes designed the organisms being examined. (go ahead quote mine this, I dare you!).

Stephen C. Meyer offers the following statement regarding the design of the biological world:
"During the last forty years, molecular biology has revealed a complexity and intricacy of design that exceeds anything that was imaginable during the late-nineteenth century. We now know that organisms display any number of distinctive features of intelligently engineered high-tech systems: information storage and transfer capability; functioning codes; sorting and delivery systems; regulatory and feed-back loops; signal transduction circuitry; and everywhere, complex, mutually-interdependent networks of parts. Indeed, the complexity of the biomacromolecules discussed in this essay does not begin to exhaust the full complexity of living systems. As even the staunch materialist Richard Dawkins has allowed, "Biology is the study of complicated things that give the appearance of having been designed for a purpose." Yet the materialistic science we have inherited from the late-nineteenth century, with its exclusive conceptual reliance on matter and energy, could neither envision nor can it now account for the biology of the information age." - The Origin of Life and the Death of Materialism by Stephen C. Meyer, Ph.D.

- First do a google search for Stephen C. Meyer, and you will find that he works for the Discovery Institute, which is a think tank of people arguing for Intelligent Design, or creationism. His Ph.D is also in history and philosophy of science, not biology and therefore is not an authority on evolution. I plan on getting my Ph.D in Anthropology, and that will not make me an authority on physics, having a Ph.D does not make you an expert in everything. He is also taking Dawkins out of context he stated that they appear to be designed, not that they are. Now that his methods and expertise are in question it is time to look at how seemingly complex things have evolved this video explains the origin of genes.

The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy states the following regarding a candid admission of Charles Darwin:
In 1885, the Duke of Argyll recounted a conversation he had had with Charles Darwin the year before Darwin's death: In the course of that conversation I said to Mr. Darwin, with reference to some of his own remarkable works on the Fertilisation of Orchids, and upon The Earthworms, and various other observations he made of the wonderful contrivances for certain purposes in nature—I said it was impossible to look at these without seeing that they were the effect and the expression of Mind. I shall never forget Mr. Darwin's answer. He looked at me very hard and said, “Well, that often comes over me with overwhelming force; but at other times,” and he shook his head vaguely, adding, “it seems to go away.”(Argyll 1885, 244)

- I really don't know what the point of this quote is... maybe it's because I have a cold and can't think clearly... but this doesn't seem to point to anything about design, no argument for design has been put forward, and all they are doing is trying to discredit evolution by putting Darwin's opinions into question, which is irrelevant to the theory. We have evidence and Darwin's personal views are meaningless.

Theory of Evolution and the Scientific Journals:
Advocates of the theory of evolution have often claimed that those who oppose the theory of evolution don't publish their opposition to the theory of evolution in the appropriate scientific literature (creationist scientists have peer reviewed journals which favor the creationist position). Recently, there has been articles which were favorable to the intelligent design position in scientific journals which traditionally have favored the theory of evolution.

- Let's put this theory to the test shall we? go to scholar.google.com and type in Intelligent Design, yes you will find just over 1,000,000 articles, but the majority of them are engineering related, as in machinery, not related to the idea of intelligent design in biology. To limit your results go to advanced search and limit the results to biology, life sciences and environmental sciences and suddenly we have about 13,600 papers, and most are referring to the public debate about Intelligent Design Vs. Evolution and none of favorable to the theory of Intelligent design. Isn't it nice when they give you a statement that you can test so easily?

Effect on Scientific Endeavors Outside the Specific Field of Biology:

Stephen Wolfram in his book A New Kind of Science has stated that the Darwinian theory of evolution has, in recent years, "increasingly been applied outside of biology." 


- Yeah this is true, evolution has been applied to anything that forms and changes over time, and is even used in anthropology to examine culture as a living organism that changes over time. Though I don't completely agree with the practice because of it's implications, social Darwinism is an atrocious practice.. but let's examine what Conservapedia has to say.


Lynsenkoism:
Evolutionary theory played a prominent role in regards to atheistic communism. Communists, in particular Stalinism, favored a version of Lamarckism called Lysenkoism developed by the atheist Trofim Denisovich Lysenko. Lsyenko was made member of the Supreme Soviet and head of the Institute of Genetics of the Soviet Academy of Sciences. Later Lysenko became President of the All-Union Academy of Agricultural Sciences. Many geneticists were imprisoned and executed for their bourgeois science, and agricultural policies based on Lysenkoism that were adopted under the Communist leaders Joseph Stalin and Mao Zedong caused famines and the death of millions.

- First off I want to say that yes these regimes were terrible, and I would never condone this abuse of power or loss of life. Now, that being said, conservapedia, admitted that Lynsenkoism is based on Lamarckism, which is not a valid theory, that acquired traits are transmitted to the offspring. This was also what was behind the eugenics movement because DNA was not well understood and what was actually transmittable to the offspring. This has nothing to do with the theory of evolution as it is understood today.

Medical Science:
he theory of evolution has had a negative effect on the field of medical science. According to Dr. Jerry Bergman the list of vestigial organs in humans has gone from 180 in 1890 to 0 in 1999. Furthermore, Dr. Bergman states the following:
Few examples of vestigial organs in humans are now offered, and the ones that are have been shown by more recent research to be completely functional (and in many cases critically so, see Bergman and Howe)...
One popular book on the human body which discussed vestigial organs stated that next to circumcision
‘… tonsillectomy is the most frequently performed piece of surgery. Doctors once thought tonsils were simply useless evolutionary leftovers and took them out thinking that it could do no harm. Today there is considerable evidence that there are more troubles in the upper respiratory tract after tonsil removal than before, and doctors generally agree that simple enlargement of tonsils is hardly an indication for surgery...’

- Alright, we didn't know then, and we know now. However, this does not disprove evolution and evolutionary science is actually very beneficial in medical science. Take for instance the bacteria which become antibiotic resistant through evolutionary processes, the understanding of zoonoses, diseases which are transmitted from animal to human, it is also used to explain the vestigial tail that some children are born with, stem cell research also utilizes evolutionary science (don't freak out pro-lifers, the best stem cells come from the umbilical cord not from aborted fetuses). For more information on evolutionary medicine I would suggest googling it yourself and see all of the advantages evolutionary science gives to medicine.


Astronomy:
Young earth creation scientist Dr. Jonathan Sarfati states that evolutionary thought has been applied to the field of astronomy. Sarfati's claim is supported by the fact that astronomers do refer to the "evolution of the universe". Sarfati asserts the evolutionary view has had a negative effect on astronomy and that arguments to support the proposed evolutionary time scales of billions of years via the field of astronomy are invalid. Creationists can cite examples of scientists stating that evolutionary ideas in astronomy have failed to have any explanatory power:

- how exactly? I'm not a physicist, or an astronomer, but Andromeda's Wake on Youtube is... and he has a great series called CrAP (Creationist Astronomy Propaganda) debunked which you can watch here. 

“...most every prediction by theorists about planetary formation has been wrong.” Scott Tremaine, as quoted by Richard A. Kerr, “Jupiters Like Our Own Await Planet Hunters,” Science, Vol. 295, 25 January 2002, p. 605

- If you think that this is quote mined then you are right. Here is the whole thing:
Astrophysicist Scott Tremaine of Princeton University sees these results and Lineweaver and Grether’s extrapolation as reasonable quantifications of trends hinted at by the discoveries so far, and he looks forward to coming discoveries. As some monitoring records approach the requisite 12 years, Doppler detection of extrasolar Jupiters may not be far off. And searches are in the works for terrestrial-sized planets by looking for planets passing in front of their stars. But Tremaine remains cautious about what these searches will turn up. Speaking as a theorist, he notes that “most every prediction by theorists about planetary formation has been wrong.”
- as you can see he is preforming what is known as academic honesty... being cautious about trying to make a definitive statement because these don't hold up well in the past.

"Attempts to find a plausible naturalistic explanation of the origin of the Solar System began about 350 years ago but have not yet been quantitatively successful, making this one of the oldest unsolved problems in modern science.” - Stephen G. Brush, A History of Modern Planetary Physics, Vol. 3 (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1996), p. 91

- Just because something has not been solved yet is no reason to determine that it will never be solved. This is a classic god of the gaps trying to fit god into anything that is not yet explained, but as time goes on those gaps are getting smaller and smaller. I also could not find this quote to determine whether or not it has been mined, but I think you get the idea about the god of the gaps arguments.

“We don’t understand how a single star forms, yet we want to understand how 10 billion stars form.” Carlos Frenk, as quoted by Robert Irion, “Surveys Scour the Cosmic Deep,” Science, Vol. 303, 19 March 2004, p. 1750.

- Guess what? This was quote mined as well, and quote mined to create another god of the gaps argument... but here is the entire passage:
"Current theories of galaxy formation can’t explain why concussive waves of star birth swept through some early galaxies but not others—and why some of those fierce stellar fires got snuffed after a few billion years. Startled by their own data, a few observers have implied that modelers of the cosmos need new ideas to describe our universe’s combustive childhood (Science, 23 January, p. 460).
Theorists aren’t yet ready to revise equations on their cluttered whiteboards, but they agree that the surveys illuminate serious flaws. “We’re starting from a shaky foundation,” says cosmologist Carlos Frenk of the University of Durham, U.K. “We don’t understand how a single star forms, yet we want to understand how 10 billion stars form.” Fellow theorist Simon White of the Max Planck Institute for Astrophysics in Garching, Germany, concurs: “The simple recipes in published models do not reproduce the star formation we see. Theorists are now having to grow up.”

“We cannot even show convincingly how galaxies, stars, planets, and life arose in the present universe.” Michael Rowan-Robinson, “Review of the Accidental Universe,” New Scientist, Vol. 97, 20 January 1983, p. 186.

- Alright, I cannot verify if this was quote mined or not because I only have access to New Scientist back to 1990... but just because we may not know is no reason to throw our hands up and say "I give up!"

In 2001, Cristina Chiappini wrote concering the Milky Way galaxy:
". . . it is an elegant structure that shows both order and complexity. . . . The end product is especially remarkable in the light of what is believed to be the starting point: nebulous blobs of gas. How the universe made the Milky Way from such simple beginnings is not altogether clear. - Cristina Chiappini, "The Formation and Evolution of the Milky Way," American Scientist (vol. 89, Nov./Dec. 2001), p. 506.

- It appears whoever has quote mined this passage did not bother reading the next paragraph:
"These models need to account for not only the large-scale gravitational forces involved in assembling the Galaxy, but also the chemical composition of its primary components, the stars. It turns out that the chemistry of the stars holds clues to how the Galaxy was made and how it has changed through time. The gas blobs that evolved into the Milky Way consisted merely of hydrogen and helium (and a smattering of lithium), the elements that were created in the Big Bang. All the other elements were literally created by the stars. Unlike the medieval alchemists, the stars can actually transmute one element into another-they are prodigious chemical factories. Nevertheless, even today hydrogen and helium make up about 98 percent of the normal matter in the universe. It's the distribution of the elements that make up the final 2 percent that makes all the difference to studies of galactic evolution."

Dr. Walt Brown provides numerous citations to the secular science literature that cite the failings of current old universe paradigm explanations in regards to the planets, stars, and galaxies.

- yeah but since you don't provide them I can only assume that they are misinterpretations and quote mined...

Origin of Life
Evolutionary thought has had an influence on origin of life research as well. For example, a 2004 article in the International Journal of Astrobiology is titled On the applicability of Darwinian principles to chemical evolution that led to life. It is also clear that early origin of life researcher Aleksandr Oparin who proposed materialist ideas regarding the origin of life was influenced by evolutionary thought. However, the current naturalistic explanations for the origin of life are inadequate.

-No! That's a bad Conservapedia! Evolution only deals with things once they exist, and not how they exist. If you want to argue against abiogenesis then use the correct terms. Evolution has never been used in science to explain how life began, it only explains how it changed once it got here. So this is completely irrelevant.

Alright, I think that is good for tonight and we are slowly getting through it, next time Dawkins and Pseudoscience... it should be fun!

Until next time,
DD



Atheism in Popular Culture

Hey all,

I promise to get back to my critique of the conservapedia page on evolution soon, probably tomorrow, but tonight I wanted to bring something up that has been on my mind recently and that is the representation of atheists in pop culture which is where I think many of the criticisms of atheism come from, though I'm sure that churches do their share as well.

There are not many atheist characters on TV shows, and of the ones that I watch I can name three main characters, and one supporting character. All three of these characters have a few things in common:

1. They are very intelligent.

2. The are aware of their intelligence and often gloat about it.

3. They are awkward in social settings, and don't get a long with many people either because they are anti-social or do not understand accepted social norms.

4. Each of these characters either had a strained relationship with their father, or their father is deceased.

5. All three are scientists.

Could you figure out who I was talking about? Well they are Gregg House from House, Temperance "Bones" Brennen from Bones and Sheldon Cooper from The Big Bang Theory, the supporting character is Sheldon's "girl friend" Amy Farrah Fowler also on the Big Bang Theory.

Why is this? Why are atheists in pop culture generally intelligent, arrogant and socially awkward, and how does this affect how atheists are treated in mainstream society?

Let's address the first question, why? Well since these shows come from the U.S. I think that there is about an 80% probability that the staff of these shows are Christian given that the population of the U.S. is 80% Christian. Why can't these characters be normal every day people? Well take a look at the list of the reasons for atheism I tackled not too long ago in my post "The A Word" and see how many of them are in the list above.

1 & 5. Intelligence and being scientists.  All of these characters are scientists, Medical Professional, Forensic Anthropology, Theoretical Physics and Neurobiology, and I believe Conservapedia listed scientism as a cause, in which science has become a new god... Which is not the case, all of these people have evaluated the evidence and found the evidence to be lacking... that's what scientists do.

What is ironic is that these characters are surrounded by other scientists who happen to be believers. House often has religious arguments with his colleagues, for a while in season 4 one of his fellows was Mormon. Brennen's partner is Catholic, and in an episode in season 1 Brennen, her partner, and all their colleagues are all trapped in the lab until Christmas Eve and discuss their faith, after Brennen brings up the Christ myth. In the Big Bang Theory Sheldon's roommate, Lennard does not openly profess a faith, however his other friends Howard is Jewish and Raj is Hindu.

Skipping 2, which will be discussed when addressing my second question.

3. Social awkwardness, I really don't know how to address this, perhaps it's because the prevailing belief of atheists is that they don't have the community that religious people do, and this affects them to the point where they have a hard time getting a long with others. Again conservapedia comes through stating that atheists tend to be quarrlesome and socially challeneged men...though they just talk about the non apologetic atheists, but the stereotype may be there.

4. Poor relationship with father. Also from conserapedia's page of the causes of atheism. House was abused by his father, and had a complete contempt for the man. Brennen's father was absent for a very large part of her life and was a bank robber and murderer and is now working on attempting to build a relationship with him. Sheldon's father died when he was young, while we don't know anything about Amy's father, but have met her mother.

What affect does this have on atheists in general? Well it creates a stereotype of atheists as overly intelligent, arrogant, socially awkward scientists, which is not a realistic representation of atheists. I know that in my case when I say I'm an atheist the assumption is that I'm a scientist of some kind and have an understanding that they don't about life's origins. I admit I am in a scientific field, anthropology, and am still a student, but what I am interested in is palaeopathology which is the study of disease in bones.... which really doesn't have much to do with evolution, but more about being able to recognize things that are not always apparent. Seriously fungal infections are hard to pin down, and other conditions, like scurvy can be missed.

That aside, there is an assumption that anyone who professes to be an atheist has answers that theists don't and that is why they don't believe. So the assumption is there that we know everything about physics, abiogenesis, evolution, and everything about everything. When we as atheists are willing and okay with the answer "I don't know." Theists are not, and it is that simple.

When it comes down to it, it is also easier to think that these people are maladaptive to the rest of society because they don't have a god in their life which shows them how to get along with others. Which is insane, all of these characters don't see the point of these social norms and chose not to participate. When you think about it there are probably many things which are considered social norms that many of us don't participate in because we don't see the point, and this will probably be obvious if you visit a place with a culture unlike your own. But these shows paint the picture of arrogant socially awkward people which do not reflect the average atheist.

If there is anything that you think I missed, or characters I may have overlooked feel free to leave a comment... I haven't gotten any comments on any of my posts yet so I don't really know how I'm doing.

Until next time,

DD